Inkscape.org
Beginners' Questions Combine shapes
  1. #1
    tore tore @tore

    I created a white circle inside a black square. Pressed combine and the shape turned whole black.

    Created the shape again and instead exported as png. Imported the png and pressed trace bitmap. Now I got what I wanted. A combined shape with an empty circle in the middle.

    Is it possible to make this combined shape in a simpler way?

  2. #2
    Polygon Polygon @Polygonβš–πŸŒΆ

    Yes:

    1. Draw square

    2. Draw ellipse and go Path->Stroke to Path

    3. Select both elements and go Path->Combine - adjust Fill color

  3. #3
    David248 David248 @David248

    When combining two objects, the results inherits of the style of the upper object : it's just white (as your circle), turn its fill to black.

    You could also use difference : here the results inherits of the style of the lower object.

  4. #4
    Polygon Polygon @Polygonβš–πŸŒΆ

    ThatΒ΄s why I added "adjust Fill color" as a last step.

  5. #5
    David248 David248 @David248
    *

    @Polygon That's what I understood, Polygon. I tought it was tore's problem and tried to explain him why his created shape was white.

    @tore Now, I read again your post and see that the shape is full black instead of full white. I don't understand, to be honest. Maybe did you modify the fill color to black and the fill rule explains why everything is black : open fill and stroke menu, tab fill, the two heart shaped icons - choose the left one.

    If I doesn't work, please send us a screenshot of your shape selected with node tool (to see if the circle appears) : use paperclip icon bottom left of reply window.

    Β 

  6. #6
    tore tore @tore
    πŸ‘

    I created white circle on top of a black rectangle first (simple shapes). (White_circle_on_top_of_black_rectangle.PNG)

    Path->combine (combine.PNG) => all white. Changed fill to black for visibility

    Did undo till I got the first shapes and then File->Export. Created PNG file. Opened the PNG file and pressed trace bitmap (tracebitmap.PNG).

    I am creating a file for cutting out a shape. Both versions will work for that but the latter one has a better visibility.

    Tracebitmap
    Combined
    White Circle On Top Of Black Rectangle
  7. #7
    tore tore @tore
    πŸ‘

    I just figured "Path->difference" made my day

  8. #8
    Polygon Polygon @Polygonβš–πŸŒΆ
    πŸ‘

    And I thought this was your goal:

  9. #9
    David248 David248 @David248
    πŸ†*

    @tore : your #6 post (second screenshot) confirms it's a matter of fill rule. The result of path > combine inherits of the fill rule of the upper object (the circle). It's fill rule was set to non-zero : that means that if subpaths have the same orientation (clockwise in my example below), the object appears full black. To cure that, you can reverse one subpath or set the fill rule to evenodd.

    To display path orientation (red arrows when using node tool), go to preferences > Tools > Node tool and enable Show Path direction on outlines (and Always show outlines).